If you’ve ever sent a trade offer in Roblox and gotten a counteroffer that felt unfair or confusing, you’re not alone. Learning how to handle Roblox trading 105 counteroffer strategies for beginners can save you from losing rare items, getting baited, or walking away frustrated. It’s not about fancy tricks it’s about knowing your item’s real value, reading the other trader’s intent, and making smart moves without overcomplicating things.

What does “105 counteroffer” even mean?

In Roblox trading, “105” refers to offers where someone tries to get slightly more value than they’re giving usually around 5% over fair value. A counteroffer is when the other trader changes your original proposal instead of accepting or declining. So a “105 counteroffer” is their attempt to tweak the deal in their favor. Beginners often panic or accept too fast because they don’t know how to respond.

When should you expect a 105 counteroffer?

You’ll usually see this happen when:

  • The trader thinks you’re new and might not know true item values.
  • They’re testing your limits to see how much you’ll give up.
  • They’re using trade baiting tactics to pressure you into saying yes.

It’s common with high-demand limiteds like Dominus, Headless, or seasonal event items. But even mid-tier UGC or older limiteds can trigger these kinds of negotiations.

Common mistakes beginners make

Don’t fall into these traps:

  • Accepting the first counteroffer Just because someone sends a counter doesn’t mean it’s their best or only option.
  • Overreacting emotionally Saying “FINE, take it!” or “Never mind then!” gives them control.
  • Not checking recent sales If you don’t know what your item sold for last week, you’re negotiating blind.
  • Ignoring red flags If they’re rushing you or refusing to explain their math, that’s a sign to pause. Learn more about those red flags here.

How to respond to a 105 counteroffer (step by step)

  1. Pause before replying. Don’t feel pressured to respond in 30 seconds. Take a minute to think.
  2. Check your item’s real market value. Use Rolimons or RBXFlip to see recent completed trades, not just listed prices.
  3. Decide your walk-away point. What’s the least you’re willing to accept? Stick to it. If they won’t meet you there, it’s okay to leave. Here’s when to walk away without guilt.
  4. Counter back with logic. Instead of saying “no,” say “I can do 102 if you add X” or “My lowest is Y based on last week’s sale.” This keeps the conversation open but grounded.
  5. Know when to stop. If they keep pushing past fair value or refuse to budge after two rounds, move on. There are thousands of traders don’t waste time on one who won’t deal fairly.

Real example: You offered a Korblox Deathspeaker for a Valkyrie Helm + 5K RAP

They counter with: “Valkyrie Helm only, no RAP.” That’s a classic 105 play they’re trying to shave off extra value. Your move? Counter back with: “I’ll drop the RAP to 3K if you add a small UGC hat.” Now you’re still gaining value, but meeting them halfway. If they say no? Walk. Someone else will trade fairly.

Why being calm matters more than being clever

Most successful traders aren’t geniuses they’re patient. They don’t chase every deal. They don’t panic when someone counters. They know that negotiating effectively means staying cool, doing quick math, and not letting ego drive decisions. The goal isn’t to “win” the trade it’s to walk away with something you’re happy with.

Quick checklist before you hit “Send” on any counter

  • ✅ Did I check Rolimons/RBXFlip for real recent sales?
  • ✅ Is this still within my personal minimum value?
  • ✅ Am I responding because I want to, or because I feel pressured?
  • ✅ Have I considered walking away if this doesn’t improve?

Start your next trade with this mindset: You’re not begging for a deal you’re offering value. And if someone tries to push a 105 counteroffer on you, now you know exactly how to handle it without stress.